AI Answer Index

Which bakery for custom cakess does AI recommend in New York City?

What each AI assistant actually answered, stored verbatim and dated.

The question we asked, verbatim

“What are the best bakery for custom cakess in New York City? Please recommend specific businesses, ranked, and cite sources if you can.”

The same text is sent to every engine, at temperature 0 where the engine supports it. Full methodology.

Latest answer from each engine

ChatGPT gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18 Run

Named, in the order given

  1. 1Magnolia BakeryNo sourceMagnolia Bakery offers a variety of custom cakes, including their signature banana pudding cake.
  2. 2Milk BarNo sourceMilk Bar is known for its innovative and playful desserts. Their custom cakes often feature unique flavors and designs.
  3. 3BakedNo sourceThis bakery is known for its artisanal cakes and desserts, offering custom cakes that are both beautiful and delicious.
  4. 4Butter LaneNo sourceButter Lane also offers custom cakes that can be tailored to your specific needs.
  5. 5Sweet Lady JaneNo sourceSweet Lady Jane offers custom cakes that are perfect for weddings and special occasions.
  6. 6Clementine BakeryNo sourcezine* and *The Knot* for their stunning cake designs. 6. **Clementine Bakery** - **Overview**: A vegan bakery that offers custom cakes made without animal products. Their cakes are known for being
  7. 7Erin McKenna's BakeryNo sourceErin McKenna's Bakery offers custom cakes that cater to dietary restrictions without sacrificing flavor.

How the answer has changed

Every run is kept rather than overwritten, so this is the record of what each engine said on each date — not a reconstruction. A run that was not captured on the day cannot be recovered afterwards.

ChatGPT · gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18 · last 6 runs, oldest first — position in the answer; a dash means not named
Business13 Oct
2026
19 Oct
2026
25 Oct
2026
1 Nov
2026
9 Nov
2026
16 Nov
2026
Magnolia Bakery111111
Milk Bar222222
Baked—33——3
Butter Lane444444
Sweet Lady Jane555555
Clementine Bakery—6———6
Erin McKenna's Bakery777667
Baked by Melissa3——33—
Cakes by Melissa6—677—
Little Cupcake Bakeshop88888—
The Buttercream Bakeshop9—————
Patisserie Chanson10—————

Named most often

Across all 20 stored answers for this question
BusinessAnswers naming themBest positionEngines
Magnolia Bakery20 of 2011
Milk Bar20 of 2021
Butter Lane20 of 2041
Sweet Lady Jane20 of 2051
Erin McKenna's Bakery19 of 2061
Baked16 of 2031
Little Cupcake Bakeshop16 of 2051
Clementine Bakery15 of 2061
Cakes by Melissa5 of 2061
Baked by Melissa4 of 2031
Flour Bakery1 of 2081
The Buttercream Bakeshop1 of 2091
Patisserie Chanson1 of 20101

Free instant check

Is your business missing from this answer?

Run a free live check against these same engines and see exactly which questions you are absent from.

Run the free check

Listed here and would rather not be? Request removal — it takes effect on submission, with no verification required and no follow-up from us.