AI Answer Index

Which financial planners does AI recommend in New York City?

What each AI assistant actually answered, stored verbatim and dated.

The question we asked, verbatim

“Who are the best financial planners in New York City? Please recommend specific businesses or practitioners, ranked, and cite sources if you can.”

The same text is sent to every engine, at temperature 0 where the engine supports it. Full methodology.

Latest answer from each engine

ChatGPT gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18 Run

Named, in the order given

  1. 1Edelman Financial EnginesCitedOne of the largest independent financial planning firms in the U.S., they offer comprehensive financial planning services.
  2. 2Wealthspire AdvisorsCitedKnown for personalized wealth management and financial planning services, they cater to high-net-worth individuals and families.
  3. 3Creative PlanningCitedA national firm with a strong presence in NYC, they provide a wide range of financial services, including investment management and estate planning.
  4. 4BMO Wealth ManagementCitedOffers a full suite of wealth management services, including financial planning, investment management, and trust services.
  5. 5Fiduciary Trust CompanyCitedSpecializes in wealth management and estate planning, with a strong reputation for fiduciary responsibility.
  6. 6AspiriantCitedA wealth management firm that provides comprehensive financial planning and investment management services.
  7. 7The Planning CenterCitedOffers a holistic approach to financial planning, focusing on personal finance, investment strategies, and retirement planning.
  8. 8Marble Arch InvestmentsCitedA boutique firm that provides personalized financial planning and investment management services.

How the answer has changed

Every run is kept rather than overwritten, so this is the record of what each engine said on each date — not a reconstruction. A run that was not captured on the day cannot be recovered afterwards.

ChatGPT · gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18 · last 6 runs, oldest first — position in the answer; a dash means not named
Business16 Oct
2026
23 Oct
2026
29 Oct
2026
6 Nov
2026
13 Nov
2026
21 Nov
2026
Edelman Financial Engines311331
Wealthspire Advisors222222
Creative Planning433443
BMO Wealth Management144514
Fiduciary Trust Company—557—5
Aspiriant566656
The Planning Center—77——7
Marble Arch Investments—881—8
Ric Edelman6———6—
Michael Kitces7—————
Carl Richards8———7—
The Colony Group———8——
Sheryl Garrett————8—
Ritholtz Wealth Management———9——
New York Life Investment Management———10——

Named most often

Across all 32 stored answers for this question
BusinessAnswers naming themBest positionEngines
Edelman Financial Engines32 of 3211
BMO Wealth Management32 of 3211
Wealthspire Advisors32 of 3221
Creative Planning32 of 3231
Aspiriant31 of 3251
Marble Arch Investments29 of 3211
Fiduciary Trust Company29 of 3241
The Planning Center23 of 3261
New York Life Investment Management6 of 32101
The Mather Group4 of 3271
Kirkland Financial4 of 3291
Ric Edelman3 of 3261
Carl Richards3 of 3271
The Colony Group2 of 3271
Ritholtz Wealth Management2 of 3291
Michael Kitces1 of 3271
Sheryl Garrett1 of 3281

Free instant check

Is your business missing from this answer?

Run a free live check against these same engines and see exactly which questions you are absent from.

Run the free check

Listed here and would rather not be? Request removal — it takes effect on submission, with no verification required and no follow-up from us.